Graduation Year

2025

Date of Submission

12-2024

Document Type

Open Access Senior Thesis

Degree Name

Bachelor of Arts

Department

Philosophy

Reader 1

Adrienne Martin

Terms of Use & License Information

Terms of Use for work posted in Scholarship@Claremont.

Abstract

This thesis examines the philosophical underpinnings and practical implications of free speech theories in the context of contemporary challenges to maintaining a trustworthy and equitable speech environment. I begin by presenting and rejecting the theory of Free Speech Exceptionalism. I maintain that a principle is needed to underlie our approach to free speech, and the principle should be based on an independent value, rather than a retrospective analysis of speech law. I argue the principles behind a thinker-based approach are particularly appealing in light of their alignment with our considered convictions related to speech. The analysis extends to the contentious issue of hate speech, contrasting a thinker-based approach with approaches advocating the legal regulation of hate speech. I ultimately conclude the importance of democratic persuasion justifies a thinker-based approach in regulating hate speech in the form of lies by elected national representatives.

Share

COinS