Date of Award
Spring 2023
Degree Type
Open Access Dissertation
Degree Name
Education PhD, Joint with San Diego State University
Program
School of Educational Studies
Advisor/Supervisor/Committee Chair
Cristina Alfaro
Dissertation or Thesis Committee Member
Paul J. Zak
Dissertation or Thesis Committee Member
Emilie Reagan
Terms of Use & License Information
Rights Information
© 2023 Maria H Keckler
Keywords
Empathy, Immersive learning, Story, Transdisciplinary research, Transformational learning, Wicked problems
Subject Categories
Education | Neurosciences | Nursing
Abstract
Background: Empathy Unfolding is a conceptual framework grounded in complexity theory and neuroeducation principles that emerged during the research process and was used to trace the impact of immersive storytelling and transformational learning on nursing education through multiple lenses and measures. The study addressed the complex and multidimensional problem of declining empathetic concern among nursing students and professionals that disproportionately impacts low-income and culturally/linguistically diverse patient communities. Methods: The mixed-methods design centered around a patient story based on actual events, produced in two-dimensional (2D) video and 180° virtual reality (VR) formats. Second-year nursing students (N=70) were randomly assigned to two groups based on modality (2D and VR). The study employed a real-time neurophysiologic immersion measurement (data collected via athletic sensors to capture brain responses while participants experienced the story), the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI) subscales for empathic concern, a behavioral choice to assess post-immersion empathetic concern, and focus groups to assess reflective and critical consciousness as measures of transformational learning. Results: The results indicated that immersive story interventions, regardless of modality, can strengthen empathy-based competence alongside core technical/clinical skills of nursing programs when coupled with reflective learning activities. The findings aligned with neuroscience research showing strong correlations between compelling storytelling, neurological immersion, and empathetic behaviors. Qualitative data from focus group reflections identified that patient advocates and self-advocacy are crucial to improving patient care and outcomes. However, nurse burnout, implicit biases, and healthcare systems that interpret empathy as tantamount to inefficiency contribute to this healthcare problem. Implications: The study suggests that identifying effective interventions that address the complexity of declining empathetic concern among nursing students is critical. Immersive storytelling micro-interventions, coupled with reflective activities, provide a mode to expose nursing students and professionals to a whole-person care model and invite them to co-create it. The Empathy Unfolding framework offers a pathway to conduct future research that addresses the gaps in nursing education identified in this study and to inform future studies focused on holistic approaches to address the multidimensional “wicked” problem.
ISBN
9798379957032
Recommended Citation
Keckler, Maria H.. (2023). Empathy Unfolding: A Complexity Neuroeducation Framework for Tracing the Impact of Immersive Storytelling and Transformational Learning on Nursing Education. CGU Theses & Dissertations, 540. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/cgu_etd/540.
